What MRI should I choose to avoid worsening tinnitus? Is Toshiba Vantage Titan 1.5T really silent?

Discussion in 'Support' started by Lesky, Feb 8, 2014.

    1. Lesky

      Lesky Member

      Tinnitus Since:
      What MRI should I choose for brain scan to LIMIT DAMAGE of worsening tinnitus, hyperacusis and ear pain?
      With sound levels ranging from 85-130 dB I am terrified beyond words. I had an open MRI brain done in 2003 and it was a trainwreck and I aborted the scan after aprox 60%. And I was in much better shape 10 years ago.

      The options I have is the following:

      Siemens Avanto 1.5 Tesla

      Is said to have acoustic noise limit of 99 dB. Personel says most of a brain scan is performed at aprox 85-95 dB.

      Claims to be able to scan Diffusion Weighted Images under 99 dB. Including DWI-EPI. I am skeptical about this as DWI normally produces dB levels of 110-120 on regular scanners.


      Peak dB level: 99 dB

      Ear muffs: Ear muffs does fit, but only with 12 dB NRR because of lack of space for bigger ear muffs.

      This MRI is only a 30 minute drive away from my home.

      More: Patient got hearing loss and tinnitus using this MRI on a routine brain scan (without hearing protection though, still must be very loud) - http://www.hindawi.com/crim/radiology/2013/510258/

      Quotes from Siemens:

      Toshiba Vantage Titan 1.5 Tesla


      The Vantage Titan is said to be the most silent MRI available according to many sources. Claims to have a 33 dB reduction on all scans thanks to a vaccuum technology called Piannissiomo. Many people on tinnitus forums have said this is the MRI to choose.


      Peak dB level according to FDA: 115-121 dB http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh_docs/pdf12/K120638.pdf
      Peak dB level according to Toshiba: 90 db

      See page 2 - Peak and A-weighted acoustic noise: http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh_docs/pdf12/K120638.pdf

      New Vantage Titan: 106.2 dB (A-weighted) 115.4 dB (peak)
      Vantage Titan 105.7 dB (A-weighted) 115.7 dB (peak)
      Vantage Titan HSR: 113 dB (A-weighted) 121.6 dB (peak)

      Ear muffs: No. Ear muffs can not be fitted to Toshibas head coil. Major disadvantage.

      This MRI is a 10 hours minute drive away from my home.


      Toshiba medical Europes swedish product specialist claims the Vantage Titan can do normal brain scan without DW-EPI sequence and not go above 85 dB.

      They also said they can do a brain scan at ONLY 70 dB with the following protocol:

      Do NOT use Diffusion Weighted Images
      Changing slice thickness from 4 to 5 mm - reducing sound from 85 dB to 70 dB. Is it really possible to perform a solid brain scan at 70 dB? It sounds too good to be true.

      A direct quote from the Toshiba product specialist:
      I contacted Toshiba Medical in ALL european countries by email and only received one response:
      More quotes from Toshibas product specialist:

      The most important question - how can the peak level of noise on the Vantage titan differ from 90 dB according to Toshiba to 120 dB according to the FDA?

      Why is it then that the sound measurements the FDA have done of the Vantage Titan is so much higher? Toshiba mentioned 113 dB in one message saying it was without vacuum. But is it really possible the FDA have measured sound levels without vacuum on 3 separate machines, on 3 separate dates spanning over several years? To me its clear something is not right about that difference.

      Has anyone here on the board had an MRI done with the Toshiba Vantage Titan? And even better have you done MRI with a different company as well and could make a comparison?

      Whats the sound difference between open and closed MRI? Some say its like 3 x times louder in a close machine, but the companys claim there is basicly no difference. Whats the truth here?

      At last, I have done alot of reading and I have seen PATIENT COMFORT mentioned many times while mentioning the acoustic noise - but never has anyone mentioned PATIENT SAFETY when it comes to the sound levels - and tinnitus, hyperacusis or sound sensitivty is not mentioned even once anywhere either. Are the manufactorers of the MRIs really not aware that people get tinnitus and hyperacusis every single day from their machines? Or do the companys simply dont care about the patients ears?

      Footnote: GE Healthcares silent scan is not mentioned here, since its only available for NEURO scan and only 1 single brain sequence at the moment.

      Thanks in advance for any advise and information you can help with.

      • Hug Hug x 1
    2. LeQuack

      LeQuack Member Benefactor

      United States of Europe
      Tinnitus Since:
      Cause of Tinnitus:
      Bad luck and bad genes
      So which one did you choose? Any other opinions?
    3. frohike

      frohike Member Benefactor

      Tinnitus Since:
      Cause of Tinnitus:
      Acoustic trauma
      Last MRI I had I was wearing earplugs, but I had a couple of pads on both sides of my head to keep it still. Cons: I couldn't wear earmuffs, pros: the pads were blocking sound because they were pressing both sides of my head. I don't recall the MRI model, it was an old one.
    4. JohnDoe

      JohnDoe Member

      Tinnitus Since:
      I wish somebody had told me that an MRI could cause ear damage before I went in. This is how I got Tinnitus. The nurse sent me in and I came out with ringing in the ears.

Share This Page